Eyes Lips Face Cosmetics (AKA ELF cosmetics) is a makeup company that specializes in not expensive products. The bulk of their items are either $1 or $3, making them a super budget friendly company. Some of their items suck, but some of them are amazing. Their studio line typically is $3, and for the most part I've liked everything I've tried (not you Makeup Removal Pen, you sucked).
My current favorite blush is the Studio line blush in Mellow Mauve, a dusty rose color that is light enough you can build it up or leave it as a light flush across your cheeks. I use this specific blush at least 4 times a week if not more, it really goes well with almost any look I want. The formula is great, though not heavily pigmented so you will need to use more of it than you would normally.
There is a slight bit of shimmer to it, but I would not label it as glittery at all. As you can tell from the picture above, I really do use this quite a bit. My mirror popped off, but normally there is a mirror in that space on the lid.
As you can see, it gives just a nice flush of color and unless you spend 10 minutes applying it you will never end up looking like a clown.
This is it on my face, just a nice and gentle bit of color. I highly recommend this particular blush, its really great.